Monday, 28 September 2009

Published September 21, 2009

Crude palm oil prices forecast to increase

Indonesian planters' PE more attractive than Malaysian planters': Citigroup

By OH BOON PING

STOCK valuations in the plantations sector are looking less attractive despite a higher earnings outlook, as most are now trading at or above their historical average price multiples, says Citigroup.

A 'buy': First Resources looks cheap relative to its peers, and its 10.4 forecast PE next year provides further upside, according to Citi

It maintains a 'buy' recommendation on First Resources at a raised target price of $1.30 and a 'sell' on Wilmar.

In a report, Citi analysts said they have raised crude palm oil price forecasts in the coming quarters. Most planters expect production to rise. But, said the analysts: 'We could see a seasonal increase in production and stocks in September 2009, but note that palm oil stocks are still unusually low. India's (third-largest buyer of vegetable oil globally) oilseeds production has improved due to rainfall in key growing areas.'

The analysts expect 'CPO prices to be range-bound over the near term, close to US$650 per tonne, barring any adverse weather developments and significant movement in oil prices beyond US$65 per barrel'.

Citi raised its CPO price estimates this year to US$650 per tonne from US$610 per tonne previously, while next year's forecast was raised to US$650 per tonne from US$550 per tonne.

Meanwhile, the United States Department of Agriculture recently raised its soybean production forecast to 88.3 million tonnes from 87.1 million tonnes and world soybean imports to 75.1 million tonnes from 74.5 million tonnes previously.

Against this backdrop, Citi prefers Indonesian planters to Malaysian ones, as the former are still trading at less demanding valuations.

For example, Malaysian planters look expensive at high PE, while Indonesian stocks are at low PE. The rich valuations of Malaysian stocks are attributable to buying support from local funds, the analysts say.

Moreover, most of the plantation landbanks in Malaysia are either freehold or are on long leases while Indonesian plantation estates are typically on 30-year leases.

'Although we do not think that the Indonesian companies will trade on a par with its Malaysian peers over the near term due to perceived corporate governance and country risks, the gap should narrow over time.'

Given the forecast price increases, higher volumes, and strengthening rupiah, Citi believes that First Resources looks set to benefit from the new scenario.

For a start, the stock looks cheap relative to its peers, and its 10.4 forecast PE next year provides further upside.

Plus, it comes with a favourable growth profile as the average age of its trees is eight years - early phase for optimum yield - and yield enhancement is likely.

This, along with rising oil extraction rate (following the new mill construction) and unplanted landbank of 112,000 hectares as at June 30, should provide favourable growth prospects for the company.

Plus, First Resources is a low-cost producer with US$200 per tonne cash cost, while management also continues to express its commitment to remaining prudent in its cash management. The stock closed at 93.5 cents on Friday.

In contrast, Wilmar looks over-priced as its 20.3 forecast PE this year and 16.8 next year are higher than its historical 13.6 PE.

As Wilmar is already a dominant player in the consumer pack cooking oil business in China, its growth there may be capped in the near term. The analysts also see limited upside in its profit margins and feel that Wilmar may not benefit substantially from any rise in CPO price level. Therefore, it recommends a 'sell' on the counter, albeit with a marginal rise in target price to $6.16. The counter closed at $6.71 on Friday.

Published September 21, 2009

COE quota may see sharp cut in mid-year review

By SAMUEL EE

(SINGAPORE) An impending supply shock in certificates of entitlement (COEs) for vehicles could be in the works, which will point to soaring COE premiums ahead.

What's ahead? With scrappage lower than expected this year, some foresee a quota reduction of even 30%

The highly anticipated mid-quota-year review is scheduled to be made known this week, keeping COE watchers on edge.

The second bidding exercise for September will close on Thursday at 4pm instead of the usual Wednesday because of today's public holiday. This is usually the time when the government announces changes to the quota for certificates of entitlement halfway into the quota year (QY). And QY09, from May 2009 to April 2010, already started the year 24.1 per cent smaller than QY08 at 83,789 COEs.

But most in the motor industry believe the mid-quota-year review will shrink the number of COEs even further. This is because while part of the quota allows the vehicle population to grow 1.5 per cent (based on the vehicle population of 872,027 as at Dec 31, 2008), the bulk is to replace vehicles likely to be deregistered. And so far, scrappage has been lower than expected.

So a cut in supply is expected - and, subsequently, rising COE premiums.

'Some people have even mentioned a 30 per cent cut but 10-20 per cent is more likely,' says Jason Lim, sales manager at multi-brand distributor Cycle & Carriage.

He explains that this is because he believes the government will not want the market to be adversely impacted by too large a drop in COE supply.

Over at a luxury dealership, a senior executive predicts a 15 per cent reduction in COEs, with the immediate reaction being surging premiums. But he adds that what happens six months down the road 'ultimately depends on the state of the economy'.

'The year-end festive season and Chinese New Year period should add pressure on premiums but beyond that, the uncertainty about a V or W-shaped recovery may cushion further rises,' he says.

One market player who is pessimistic about this week's quota announcement is Vincent Ng, product manager at Kah Motor, the authorised Honda distributor, who says he is looking at a drastic 30 per cent reduction.

One reason is that the monthly deregistration rate from April to August this year has been consistently lower compared with the same month a year ago, ranging from 19 per cent to 29.4 per cent.

'The minister for transport has indicated that he wants the COE quota to reflect the actual rate of deregistration more accurately,' says Mr Ng. 'This means that based on the current trend, the cut should be about 30 per cent.'

Specifically, he says that could result in up to 900 fewer Category A 'small car' COEs, 391 fewer Cat B 'big car' COEs and 430 disappearing from the Cat E open category per month.

The current monthly quota is 2,791 Cat A COEs, 1,519 Cat B COEs and 1,432 for Cat E.

'Since demand doesn't look like it's going to soften soon, that can only mean that premiums will rise significantly,' says Mr Ng.

Cycle & Carriage's Mr Lim is more sanguine about commercial vehicle COEs though. Cycle & Carriage also carries goods vehicles and this COE category was hit hard by a 28.1 per cent shortfall at the start of QY09. Mr Lim is of the opinion that after the substantial cuts for Category C over the last two years, there will not be a further drop.

'At most it will be a very slight change because commercial vehicles are used for industry and with the economy growing again, a further cut may hurt the recovery,' he says.

Published September 21, 2009

Financial advisers defend stance on exit offers

They say claims that they endorse deals unfair to minority investors are off the mark

By JAMIE LEE

(SINGAPORE) What's fair to some is foul to others. It's a market reality that investors have to accept, industry players say.

'A de-listing offer that is not attractive to minority shareholders can still be considered 'fair and reasonable'.'

- Brendan Goh,
of DMG & Partners Securities

While recent privatisation and takeover deals may seem unattractive, independent financial advisers (IFAs) and bankers say claims that they are endorsing deals that are unfair to minority investors are off the mark.

They also refute suggestions that they should look out for the interests of minority shareholders, and argued that obtaining a consensus from all shareholders on an offer price would be extremely difficult, if not impossible.

This comes after the Singapore Exchange (SGX) recently reminded companies to make exit offers that are deemed 'reasonable' to all shareholders. The SGX also told IFAs to avoid qualifying their opinions under different investment horizons.

The regulator said that 'opinions qualified by diverse investment horizons do not meet the requirements of the rules', meaning that IFAs cannot have different calls for investors with a long-term view and those with a short-term horizon.




While making a recommendation regardless of the investment horizon taken by shareholders is an appealing idea to some, industry players are against the removal of such qualifiers, given that assessing 'borderline' deals is already tough enough. 'If SGX disallows this, IFAs will have to take greater risks and put their neck out with their calls,' said Ding Hock Chai, co-head of corporate finance at Kim Eng Capital.

Most recent local deals have won approval from IFAs as being fair and reasonable, including those at CK Tang, Man Wah Holdings and recently, Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing.

A rare case was when DMG & Partners Securities said the offer by Kingboard Chemical to take Elec & Eltek International Company private was 'neither fair nor reasonable under current market conditions'.

IFAs typically judge an offer price based on an assessment of the company's net asset value (NAV), the price-to-earnings ratio and trading liquidity, as well as the rationale behind the de-listing or takeover.

These are usually benchmarked against industry measures or similar deals done recently, so as to check if offer prices are in line with the offers made in other transactions.

Most recent offers here have offered little premium to the last traded stock price or the company's NAV. In Chartered's case for example, the bid of $2.68 per share offered a premium of less than one per cent to the last traded share price.

And in the fiercely debated privatisation of retailer CK Tang, the Tang brothers' offer was deemed by minority shareholders to be unfair since it did not match the company's net asset value and did not factor in the value of the redevelopment potential of its flagship store.

But given the lingering uncertainty over the economic recovery and the poor valuations existing now, IFAs say the financial terms of such deals are still reasonable under the current circumstances.

'The standard of care required of an IFA is to assess whether a de-listing offer is 'fair and reasonable',' said Brendan Goh, head of corporate finance at DMG & Partners Securities told BT.

'A de-listing offer that is not attractive to minority shareholders can still be considered 'fair and reasonable',' he pointed out.

A banker who declined to be named told BT: 'The whole world is at the stage where we're wondering, are we really headed for full recovery? If it's a recovery, then all right, the price may not be attractive enough because without the offer, the share price can go higher. But now, no one knows.'

IFAs are also perturbed by SGX's suggestion that deals should be reasonable to all shareholders. They noted that it is difficult to achieve consensus, since different investors had plonked money into stocks at different times and at different prices.

'You will never get to a conclusion if you say the deal has to be reasonable to every shareholder,' said one IFA who declined to be named. 'If someone had gotten the shares at $2 but for the last five years, the share price traded at around 30 cents, does that mean I need to offer $2 to be able to satisfy the shareholder who came in at that level? No, the offer has to be fair or reasonable given the current circumstances.'

IFAs also rebutted criticism that they tend to favour majority shareholders making de-listing offers, arguing that they are appointed by independent directors and that board members involved in the deals are kept out from the IFA nomination and assessment process.

However, they pointed out that they are not crusaders for minority investors either.

'Shareholders of the same class of shares enjoy equal rights, be it minority or majority shareholders,' said DMG's Mr Goh.

'Minority shareholders are beginning to see IFAs as instruments for increasing value for them, which is not correct,' said the IFA who declined to be named. 'That should be the role of the financial advisers, whose job is to negotiate a better deal for the company.'

IFAs added that shareholders have the option of voting down deals during shareholders' meetings. For a de-listing to go through, the offerer must garner 75 per cent of votes represented at the meeting and have less than 10 per cent of votes opposing the deal.

Minorities can also take their grievances to court, although if there is an IFA report that states an offer is fair, it would make it difficult for them to prove that there was minority oppression. 'There is no in-principle reason why the minority shareholders cannot commence a claim under Section 210 of the Companies Act for minority oppression,' said one litigation lawyer. 'However, I suspect that the difficulty may be in proving the acts of oppression or unfair prejudice. This is because there would normally be a report by an IFA and a recommendation by the independent directors. If the IFA report says that the offer is reasonable, then it is hard to prove otherwise.'

CK Tang's case - in which the offerers held a stake of more than 75 per cent and thus had a far higher chance of pushing the offer through - provides an interesting question of whether a company's shareholding structure should be addressed as part of the IFA's assessment.

'The offer may not be fair but if the IFA believes that it's going to go through anyway, then he might well conclude that it is reasonable,' said the IFA who declined to be named. In such cases, there could be some clarity over how reasonableness is defined, such as referring reasonableness to 'the practicality of the situation rather than the fundamental value', he added.

Some jurisdictions such as Australia define 'fair' and 'reasonable' separately in such instances. Though there have been calls for SGX to clarify the terms 'fair' and 'reasonable', there are practical considerations.

'It will be extremely difficult for SGX to clearly define such terms. Having prescriptive rules may result in other issues and technicalities, which are difficult to enforce and may add to confusion,' said Mr Goh.